Education
How to Read Expert Advisor Performance Statistics
SmartEA Research, 2026-06-17, updated 2026-11-12, 6 min read

Short answer: read an Expert Advisor's return only next to its maximum drawdown, and judge drawdown by equity (including open losses), not just balance. Then check profit factor and the number of trades for the quality of the edge, the length of the track record for how many market conditions it covers, and the equity curve for how smoothly the results were earned. No single statistic is enough, and none predicts the future.
The same numbers appear in two places: live account trackers such as MyFXBook, and the MT5 Strategy Tester report. This guide explains both.
Live results vs backtests
- Live tracked accounts (for example on MyFXBook) show real trades with real spreads, slippage and execution. Their weakness is length: a live record may cover only one or two kinds of market.
- Backtests can cover many years and conditions, and you can run them yourself. Their weakness is realism: they simulate execution and can be over-fitted to the past.
The strongest evidence is both together: a long backtest you ran yourself, consistent with a live or demo account over the same recent period. Our guide on how to backtest an EA in the MT5 Strategy Tester covers the backtest side.
Gain (return)
The headline growth figure. Trackers such as MyFXBook usually show a time-weighted "Gain", which removes the effect of deposits and withdrawals, so it reflects the strategy rather than money added. Absolute gain, by contrast, is affected by deposits. A large gain on its own says little: it may have come with a deep drawdown, a very short period or a risk level you would never use.
Maximum drawdown: the number that matters most
Drawdown is the largest fall from a peak before a new high. Read it as the price the strategy paid for its return.
- Balance drawdown only counts closed trades.
- Equity drawdown includes floating losses on open positions.
For grid and basket EAs the difference can be large, because losing positions stay open until the basket closes. A smooth balance line with a much deeper equity drawdown is the typical signature of a grid strategy. On MyFXBook, compare the drawdown figure with the equity chart; in an MT5 backtest report, look at "Equity Drawdown Maximal" and "Equity Drawdown Relative". Our article on grid vs martingale vs breakout EAs explains why.
Monthly returns
The monthly table shows how results were distributed over time. Look for consistency and recovery, not perfection. A strategy that made most of its profit in one or two months is riskier than its total suggests. Also note how long the longest losing period lasted: could you have stayed with it?
Win rate
The share of trades closed in profit. It is easy to over-value. A strategy can win 90% of trades and still lose money if the occasional loss is large; another can win 40% and be profitable because its winners are much larger. Grid EAs often show very high win rates because each basket closes at a profit unless it is cut. Always read win rate with average win, average loss and profit factor.
Profit factor
Gross profit divided by gross loss. Above 1.0 means the strategy made more than it lost; 1.5 means $1.50 earned for every $1.00 lost. Treat very high values with caution when they come from few trades or a short period. For grid EAs, profit factor based on closed trades can look excellent while large floating losses are still open.
Number of trades and track record length
Statistics from 30 trades are much less reliable than from 3,000. Likewise, three months of history rarely include a strong trend, a quiet holiday market and several major news shocks. Prefer longer records, and be wary of a new live account started after an older one was closed.
Sharpe ratio and related measures
The Sharpe ratio relates average return to its variability. Higher means smoother returns for the same gain. Different sites calculate it differently (from trades, days or months), so compare Sharpe values only within the same source. MT5 reports also show the recovery factor (net profit divided by maximum drawdown), which is a simple way to compare return per unit of pain.
The equity curve
The chart summarises everything above. A steady climb with shallow dips that recover is what a robust strategy tends to look like. Steep spikes followed by cliffs, long flat periods, or a balance line far above the equity line all deserve questions.
Scaling statistics to your own account
Published statistics come from one account, one balance and one risk setting. Before you use them to decide, translate them to your situation:
- Risk setting: if the tracked account uses twice the lot per dollar you plan to use, expect roughly half the percentage drawdown and half the return, all else equal.
- Balance and minimum lot: on a smaller account, rounding up to the broker's minimum lot can make your real risk higher than the published figures.
- Broker: spread, commission, swap and server time all change results, especially for short-term and time-based strategies.
- Start date: starting at the beginning of a drawdown feels very different from starting after one. Your experience depends on when you begin.
Red flags in published statistics
- Only a growth chart, with no drawdown or equity figures.
- Very short track records presented as proof.
- Results shown on a different risk setting from the one being sold.
- Hidden or disabled trading history on a tracked account.
- A backtest screenshot you cannot reproduce with the same settings.
How to compare two EAs
- Return and maximum equity drawdown together: which gave more return per unit of drawdown?
- Profit factor and number of trades: is the edge real and based on enough trades?
- Track record length: do the results cover different market conditions?
- Monthly table and equity curve: consistency and recovery.
- Your own test: reproduce the results in the Strategy Tester and on demo with your broker.
- Your sizing: scale the drawdown to the risk level you would actually use.
Applying this to our EAs
For our gold EAs, we describe the strategy, the default settings and the risks on each EA page, and where we publish a MyFXBook link you can check the live account there. More importantly, every EA runs for free in the Strategy Tester, so you can produce your own statistics with your broker's data:
- Smart Rider Gold EA and Smart Archer Gold EA are grid basket EAs: judge them by equity drawdown, not win rate.
- Smart Striker Gold EA is a breakout EA with a stop loss on every trade: expect a lower win rate and look at losing streaks.
For a broader checklist, see what to check before buying a forex EA.
Frequently asked questions
Which statistic is the most important?
Return and maximum equity drawdown read together. Profit factor, number of trades and track record length tell you how much to trust them.
Is a high win rate good?
Not necessarily. Win rate ignores the size of wins and losses. Grid EAs often have very high win rates and large occasional drawdowns.
Why does MyFXBook's gain differ from my own calculation?
Trackers use time-weighted returns that neutralise deposits and withdrawals, and update on their own schedule. Absolute gain and simple balance growth give different numbers.
Can I trust a backtest?
Trust one you ran yourself with realistic settings more than a screenshot. Even then, a backtest shows how the EA behaved, not what it will do.
How long should a track record be?
Long enough to include different market conditions and a losing period. A few months is rarely enough.
Performance statistics describe the past. Backtests and past results do not predict future results. Trading with leverage carries a high risk of loss; only trade money you can afford to lose.
Follow SmartEA Insider on Telegram
SmartEA Insider: results of our own live accounts, new versions and release notes. No trade signals.


